Willie Miller (former Aberdeen and Scotland defender) – Do we really need sweeping changes? Is the problem with academy pathways? What, exactly, is wrong with Scottish football? – We’ve reached three major tournaments, fans are backing the league structure, and the numbers are strong. – I support the authorities and clubs coming together. There are real issues and likely resistance, but the aim should be a clear route for young players to reach first teams.
Steven Pressley (Dundee manager and former Scotland defender) – We’re finally seeing more of our youngsters getting games in the lower leagues through loan partnerships. Early experience in competitive men’s football is crucial. – The players you least expect often emerge once given minutes—opportunity unlocks surprises.
Stephen Robinson (Aberdeen manager) – The league should be larger. In England’s 24-team divisions, there are periods where you can give kids six or seven games without major consequences. – Here, every match has stakes—Europe, top six, or relegation. Other leagues use squad and homegrown quotas. We’re doing our part.
Andy Halliday (former Hearts, Motherwell and Rangers midfielder) – We need major change from the ground up. Require a set number of Scottish players in matchday squads and create a clearer bridge from youth to first team. – At grassroots level, rethink formats—delay 11v11, consider extending nine-a-side—so technical development comes first.