-
Ian Darke
The Premier League can quickly become a realm of shattered aspirations for even the most prestigious players. Where there are highlights, there are also narratives of struggle and unmet expectations.
Here’s my lineup of gifted players who have so far failed to meet their potential.
While it may seem unkind to include a player recovering from a leg fracture sustained against Tottenham Hotspur on December 20, it’s evident that Isak, who had been out of sync following a striking dispute with Newcastle before completing a late £125 million transfer to Anfield, was already underperforming prior to the injury.
Ironically, Isak’s brilliant strike against Tottenham occurred just milliseconds before Micky van de Ven’s tackle that has sidelined him until at least March. Nevertheless, given his talent, this could merely be a rocky beginning to what may develop into a successful career at Anfield.
Once viewed as an elite striker upon his arrival at Old Trafford, the Slovenian has yet to prove his worth. With just two goals in 14 matches before Christmas, his performance has been disappointing, particularly with Ruben Amorim preferring a revitalized Mason Mount in a floating No. 9 role.
Acquired for £55 million as an upgrade for the right wing, Elanga has struggled to find his footing at Newcastle and needs to enhance his performance levels. Despite his impressive speed, he has not delivered enough end product, leading to his loss of a starting position in favor of Jacob Murphy, who has gained Eddie Howe’s trust.
Though he has had some standout moments, the player, who moved for £52 million, seems to have fallen down the pecking order at Stamford Bridge, starting only four times in the Premier League. With Pedro Neto, Alejandro Garnacho, and Estêvão ahead of him, he may need a couple of standout substitute appearances to change manager Enzo Maresca’s opinion.
– Connelly: The best teams in European soccer right now
– Ogden: Top PL transfers of last summer’s window
– O’Hanlon: Ranking top clubs’ January transfer needs
Everton fans appreciate his hard work and desire to succeed, but with just one goal to his name thus far this season, he hasn’t provided the prolific scoring that the team has longed for, despite an 11-goal season at Villarreal last year. Barry has the potential to excel, but he must become more clinical.
James McAtee, Midfielder, Nottingham Forest
McAtee is an enjoyable player to watch but has yet to make significant strides at Forest after a £30 million transfer from Manchester City. With the club’s main playmaker, Morgan Gibbs-White, in prime form, it seems there’s little room for both in the starting XI. However, McAtee possesses great talent, and his opportunity will eventually arrive.
Acquired for £40 million to eventually replace left-back Andy Robertson, he has struggled to replicate the form that made him a standout at Bournemouth. He briefly lost his spot to Robertson during a tough season for Liverpool but has since reclaimed it as the team has found some momentum, and he will be looking to prove that his shaky start was merely a phase.
His disappointing performance this season has been a significant letdown for Wolves fans, particularly after netting 14 Premier League goals last year, as he has only tallied one from 15 appearances this term. A missed penalty against Brentford only compounded the frustration, and concerns regarding his commitment have emerged as the club’s plight has worsened, accumulating just two points from their first 18 games.
His skill was evident in a relegated Southampton team last season, leading to his signing with Everton. However, the 19-year-old winger has had limited opportunities, with Iliman Ndiaye and Jack Grealish in excellent form, alongside Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall excelling in the No. 10 position. Dibling has started only one league match and will need to step up with Ndiaye away for the Africa Cup of Nations. Fortunately, he still has time on his side.
Aït-Nouri seems to have fallen out of manager Pep Guardiola’s plans during his inaugural season at City following a lavish move from Wolves, and an ankle injury has not aided his cause. With Nico O’Reilly performing exceptionally at left back, Aït-Nouri must avoid becoming a sidelined player at City, like former midfielder Kalvin Phillips did.
Chelsea has a penchant for signing young prospects who could appreciate in value, and Hato fits this mold. Once part of the Ajax squad competing in the UEFA Europa Conference League at just 16, he was regarded as a promising talent capable of playing in both the center back and left back positions. Yet, he has seen minimal game time at Stamford Bridge, and a January loan seems beneficial, although coach Maresca may prefer to keep him as defensive cover.
1:13
Was Manchester United’s win in their new formation merely coincidental?
Gab Marcotti and Julien Laurens examine Manchester United’s 1-0 victory over Newcastle and whether it was influenced by manager Ruben Amorim’s formation change.
James Trafford, Goalkeeper, Manchester City
Trafford believed he was signing on to be City’s primary goalkeeper and made a start in the first three matches. Unfortunately, the acquisition of world-class goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma from Paris Saint-Germain has left Trafford relegated to the bench, during a year when he had hoped to improve his chances for the England World Cup squad next summer.
Xavi Simons, Midfielder, Tottenham Hotspur
Joining from RB Leipzig, Simons came with high expectations and seemed poised to be the ideal playmaker for Tottenham in the absence of injured midfielder James Maddison. However, apart from brief flashes, including a solo goal against Brentford, he hasn’t consistently impressed and often appears too physically fragile for the rigors of the Premier League.