A lot can happen in a year, yet sometimes everything stays the same. Just ask Eddie Howe, who is celebrating another home victory against Manchester United, a match that stirs mixed emotions about the season Newcastle United has experienced.
This win might just be the most satisfying, turning into one of those memorable nights at St James’ Park thanks to a controversial red card for Jacob Ramsey and a stunning winner from William Osula.
Advertisement
While Newcastle’s fourth consecutive home victory against United emphasizes their recent superiority in this matchup, it starkly contrasts with where they were nearly a year ago—a sobering realization for Howe.
Newcastle’s dominant 4-1 victory over United in April 2025 had firmly established them as one of the league’s most electrifying teams, nearing a Champions League return with a fifth-place finish in the Premier League. Fast forward to March 2026, and despite a win that will surely be cherished by home supporters, the Magpies languish in 12th place, trailing their rivals by 12 points.
Osula’s goal ignited celebration at St James’ Park (Action Images via Reuters)
This contrast is bittersweet for Howe. While he has achieved great success at Newcastle, this season might feel like a step back (at least for now). With the potential for significant player departures—as was seen last summer—the club’s activity in the transfer market will be crucial in determining the path forward.
Advertisement
Nonetheless, Howe remains one of the league’s finest at extracting top performances from his players, as highlighted by their display, which exposed the weaknesses of their opponents on the night.
Despite questionable refereeing threatening to overshadow the high-stakes Premier League clash—referee Peter Bankes sent Ramsey off for allegedly diving—the outcome was ultimately shaped by Howe’s strategy and the commitment of his ten available players.
Ramsey received a second yellow for simulation just before half-time (Getty Images)
A turning point came when Bruno Fernandes committed a reckless foul, resulting in a clear penalty converted by Anthony Gordon. However, just before half-time, Casemiro equalized with a header, leaving the hosts feeling disheartened.
Advertisement
As both teams headed down the tunnel at half-time, the stands erupted with boos, reflecting a sense of injustice over the red card, particularly since it wasn’t reviewed by VAR.
Despite this, Newcastle didn’t rely on luck, instead, they created their chances, with Aaron Ramsdale making impressive saves to deny Leny Yoro and a long-range attempt from Joshua Zirkzee.
Gordon calmly finished just after Ramsey’s dismissal (Getty Images)
Newcastle displayed determination in defense, energy in midfield, and when the opportunity arose, they struck back, albeit with few clear chances as the visitors probed for an advantage after Ramsey’s red card.
Advertisement
Despite their numerical edge, United struggled to create meaningful opportunities, often being contained on the wings and occasionally outmatched in midfield.
Having played three matches against opponents who received red cards, the lack of athleticism in midfield was apparent, paralleling issues from their prior matches. With less threat from wide areas, they seemed unable to capitalize on the advantage.
This became a two-fold issue at St James’, exemplifying the need for the club to make smart signings in the summer transfer window, both for depth and key starting positions.
While a return of 19 points from eight games looks promising under Carrick, the team has faced inconsistent performances, especially against West Ham, Everton, and Palace prior to this disappointing outing at St James’.
Osula’s goal lifted the Magpies to 12th place, while United remained in third (Getty Images)
Ultimately, Newcastle capitalized on United’s inability to deliver, with Osula finding the perfect moment to score, cutting in from the right wing and curling a spectacular shot into the far corner.
Advertisement
For Newcastle, this goal showcased the potential of Howe’s stewardship, but also highlighted the season’s tribulations—reminding all involved that there is still time to turn things around. For Manchester United, it served as a reality check, revealing that despite their progress since the April 2025 match, they still have much work ahead if they aim to build a squad that can contend for prestigious titles.