The 2025-26 season for Everton is shaping up to be one of the most captivating narratives in the Premier League. With David Moyes back at Goodison, now known as Hill Dickinson Stadium, he has swiftly begun the task of reconstructing a squad that was just months away from potential relegation. Having achieved 11 clean sheets to this point, only Arsenal has a superior record, while Everton has remarkably conceded just 16 goals in away matches all season. Currently sitting eighth with 46 points, they trail fifth-placed Liverpool by a mere three points as the race for European qualification heats up. The atmosphere at the club has undoubtedly transformed.
What James Garner’s Contract Extension Means for the Team
Pete O’Rourke has reported that James Garner’s contract extension in January has sent positive signals throughout the dressing room. Players are increasingly optimistic that the club can retain its top talents and forge a lasting success under Moyes. Given that Everton last participated in European competitions during the 2017-18 season, a return would signify a significant achievement for the club.
Advertisement
With strong interest from Aston Villa, the Toffees have made it clear they are unwilling to entertain offers for the midfielder, reinforcing their belief that the new deal secures his future. Garner has notched up eight goal contributions this season, scoring two times in 31 league appearances, and his Non-Penalty xG per 90 minutes of 0.13 places him in the 56th percentile among top-flight midfielders.
BRIGHTON, ENGLAND – JANUARY 31: James Garner of Everton inspects the pitch prior to the Premier League match between Brighton & Hove Albion and Everton at Amex Stadium on January 31, 2026 in Brighton, England. (Photo by Steve Bardens/Getty Images)
In the last five matches, Everton has gleaned nine points—more than Liverpool, Chelsea, or Brentford during the same stretch—demonstrating that the squad is responding to the ambition of the club’s leadership. (Via Footy Stats)
Does Retaining Garner Reflect Everton’s Renewed Ambition?
Absolutely, and its significance is greater than many realize. For years, Everton struggled to retain key players, often losing them to wealthier clubs, which portrayed a lack of ambition to the squad and rival teams alike. Securing Garner on a long-term contract during a winter transfer window marked by Aston Villa’s public interest underscores that The Friedkin Group is serious about their objectives.
Advertisement
At this time last season, supporters were anxious that Everton might commence their new stadium journey in the Championship. Instead, they are now contending for a Champions League spot from an eighth-place position with just seven matches remaining. This marks a complete turnaround. Retaining Garner is not just a routine transfer decision; it signifies the club’s evolving identity, and the players have clearly embraced this new direction.