Former Everton chief executive Keith Wyness recently shared a candid opinion on the transfer rumors connecting Borussia Dortmund midfielder Julian Brandt with a potential move to Goodison Park. In an exclusive conversation with Football Insider on their Inside Track podcast, the seasoned consultant expressed skepticism regarding these claims.
Wyness Questions Julian Brandt’s Fit at Everton
Having led the club’s operations from 2004 to 2009, Wyness argued that the German international wouldn’t genuinely elevate the current Everton squad. He highlighted the heavy financial implications of Brandt’s anticipated wages relative to his actual contributions on the pitch. While he recognized Brandt’s talent, Wyness maintained that the player doesn’t align with the specific demands of Premier League midfield battles.
Advertisement
In addition, the former CEO pivoted the discussion towards a more promising candidate, Arsenal’s young talent Myles Lewis-Skelly. He asserted that Everton would be better served pursuing the adaptable teenager over the Dortmund midfielder.
Wyness endorsed the idea of bringing Lewis-Skelly to Merseyside, contrasting the feasibility of that transfer with the skepticism surrounding Brandt. He ultimately rejected the notion of the German’s arrival as an unlikely and potentially unnecessary expense for a club that must be strategic in its recruitment this summer.
Is Julian Brandt a True Upgrade for the Toffees’ Midfield?
DORTMUND, GERMANY – FEBRUARY 28: Julian Brandt of Borussia Dortmund dribbles the ball during the Bundesliga match between Borussia Dortmund and FC Bayern München at Signal Iduna Park on February 28, 2026, in Dortmund, Germany. (Photo by Pau Barrena/Getty Images)
Advertisement
Wyness’s assertion that Brandt offers no upgrade is a bold stance. The German international enjoyed a productive 2025/26 season with Borussia Dortmund, scoring 10 goals and providing 3 assists across all competitions. His technical ability is a major asset, consistently creating space and executing passes that penetrate defensive lines. However, he has faced criticism for his lack of defensive tenacity and occasional inconsistency in physical challenges, traits less favored in a more combative midfield setup.
Currently, Everton relies on the hardworking players like James Garner and the experience of Idrissa Gana Gueye, complemented by the creative flair of Jack Grealish on loan. Typically, signing a player of Brandt’s caliber indicates ambition, yet I find myself echoing Wyness’s cautious approach regarding finances.
While Brandt may statistically eclipse many of Everton’s existing options, his substantial wage demands could impede the club’s financial stability. The team cannot afford to repeat earlier mistakes by overpaying for established talents who may struggle to adapt to the pace of English football at this stage in their careers. Nevertheless, I suspect that the Toffees may still pursue Brandt.