We reached out to gather your opinions on the potential hiring of Eirik Horneland as Aberdeen’s new manager.
Here’s a glimpse of your feedback:
Robert: Scottish clubs are more than just workplaces; they are emotional institutions. Having a Scottish manager is significant not merely due to nationality but because they inherently grasp the emotional significance of the badge, the rivalries, the club’s history, and the impact of a victory on both fans and players.
Advertisement
Lenny: He lacks familiarity with the Scottish game. Didn’t we dismiss Jimmy Thelin, who had a better track record and hailed from the same area? Why are we considering this path again?
Douglas: While Horneland may or may not be a suitable candidate, he’s not nearly as compelling as Jens Berthel Askou, who has consistently demonstrated his value in the Premiership. Even if we can’t secure him, it would be a mistake not to pursue him.
Andrew: I don’t see how it matters who the next manager is; the club’s issues run deeper than just replacing the manager. Another summer overhaul of players will only lead us into the same cycle again.
Neil: Like Jimmy Thelin, Horneland has enjoyed success in Scandinavia, but his record overseas raises some doubts. His teams tend to be predictable and can struggle to adjust once opponents figure them out. Does that sound familiar? Aberdeen needs a manager who can blend tactical adaptability with the capacity to instill determination and confidence—the true challenge in the Scottish Premiership.
Advertisement
Phileas: Over the past few decades, Aberdeen has had multiple Scandinavian managers, but none have reached the heights of Alex Ferguson or Derek McInnes. Where is the ambition? Simply finishing in the top half isn’t sufficient.