Imported Article – 2026-07-14 22:34:43

Manchester United is in need of a dedicated expert to manage their midfield transition, particularly with Michael Carrick now at the helm. His first signing has been Andrey Santos, purchased for an initial £48 million. Carrick is also looking to acquire Youri Tielemans for £35 million. Initially, it seemed they would also pursue Ederson for a similar fee, but those plans have been put on pause due to the Brazilian failing a medical.

The midfield shake-up at Old Trafford seems to be gaining momentum, though some observers might suggest it veers off track with the changes in player targets. Notable names like Elliot Anderson, Mateus Fernandes, and apparently Aurelien Tchouameni, who has recently extended his contract with Real Madrid. It appears that United are now targeting lower-tier options, facing competition from clubs known for their financial prowess. They might reflect on previous overspending, as last summer saw them fork out £70 million for a forward, while this transfer window seems more aligned with the £30 million-£50 million midfielders.

The financial implications are telling. This time around, it seems United has been outmatched by their rivals. The combined cost of Tielemans and Santos stands at approximately £85 million, compared to the £100 million spent by Tottenham for Mateus Fernandes. Even the addition of Ederson would only bring the total to approximately £116 million, slightly more than the £110 million Manchester City agreed to pay for Elliot Anderson.

As United works towards their goal of a revamped £2 billion stadium, there is a prevailing sense of financial constraint as they rebuild the team. Some intentions haven’t materialized as planned; they are still unable to offload Manuel Ugarte due to his World Cup injury, while Barcelona chose not to exercise their option to buy Marcus Rashford. Andre Onana has again been loaned out to Trabzonspor without being sold. With limited avenues to enhance their budget, United find themselves in a tight spot.

Advertisement

Compounding the issue, the midfield market is experiencing a surge in prices. This has partly been driven by Tottenham, who splashed £100 million on Tonali and an additional £85 million on Fernandes. On the other hand, United have made strategic acquisitions: Ederson’s contract at Atalanta is nearing its end, making him an attractive choice. Tielemans, with a release clause in his Aston Villa contract, offers good value; however, in today’s market where midfielders command upwards of £100 million, it’s rare to find players of his caliber at a significantly lower price. Although he is 29, this is not akin to investing in Casemiro when he was in his 30s, but it does raise concerns about the potential lack of resale value.

However, acquiring Tielemans makes strategic sense; it weakens a competitor, especially given that both clubs might be vying for Champions League qualification. With Amadou Onana’s absence, Villa’s midfield is looking vulnerable, and Tielemans may well prove to be the difference-maker, having had a productive spell under Unai Emery. United would likely be satisfied with securing Champions League qualification twice in the next three years while also adding a European trophy, following Tielemans’ previous recognition as their Player of the Year for an outstanding 2024-25 season.

There may be lingering thoughts within United regarding Tielemans, particularly about missing the opportunity to sign him earlier or at a lower price. It’s perplexing that other clubs did not consider him during 2023, allowing Villa to acquire him on a free transfer while the demand for midfielders surged to £100 million. United, among others, regret not pursuing him sooner, ultimately opting to acquire Sofyan Amrabat or purchasing Manuel Ugarte, each of whom are more defensive-oriented players lacking Tielemans’ finesse.

Advertisement

Santos, on the other hand, presents a different scenario, not merely due to his background with Chelsea, whose tumultuous season included a dismal 10th-place finish. Some might argue that United has landed the third-choice midfielder from a mid-table club, despite the fact that his fellow competitors, Enzo Fernandez and Moises Caicedo, belong to the elite class of £100 million players.

Santos started only 13 league matches last season, yet his passing accuracy and ability to complete progressive passes at a high rate earned him attention from United. Still, the transfer fee feels steep for a player with limited experience.

Even with Tielemans joining, questions remain about whether United has successfully replaced Casemiro. The Belgian, like Kobbie Mainoo, serves as more of a complementary player rather than a direct replacement. This situation may leave Santos with the burden of being the first-choice option by default.

Nonetheless, United has not completely dismissed the idea of re-engaging with Ederson. Acquiring two relatively economical players could potentially allow them to allocate funds elsewhere. Despite the arrival of two central midfielders, the necessity for a third remains evident.

Advertisement

If their leading targets continue to elude them, there is a risk that the ambitious overhaul envisioned by United—which likely centered around players like Tchouameni, Anderson, and Fernandes—might yield compromises, ultimately resulting in a midfield lineup that falls short of the caliber seen at clubs like Arsenal or Manchester City. Perhaps Tottenham’s more expensive rebuild will yield superior quality.

With Michael Carrick’s extensive experience as a midfielder at United, totaling 464 appearances, he is well-equipped for this challenge. The success of Tielemans, Santos, and any future recruits will depend not only on impressing Carrick but also on establishing themselves as his worthy successors.